Am I Better Off Dead?

Was I better off dead
Than to be stuck in my head?
23 hours a day
For damn near a year straight.

In response to one crisis,
They created another:
A pandemic of mental health illnesses
We now suffer.

This one-year lockdown,
An unexpected abnormality,
Has me struggling to maintain
My grip on reality.

Am I better off dead
And at peace with myself
Than to be cruelly and unusually punished
In this beast that’s my cell?

COMMENTARY

This poem is an attempt to capture the unbelievable amount of stress placed on inmates who have been forced — in the name of “safety” — to be locked down for an entire year, to prevent the spread of COVID-19 through the prison system.

I don’t mean to suggest I’m suicidal as a result of this lockdown, but I wonder how many of us are. On the one hand, preventative measures were needed to prevent a prisonwide outbreak in the jails, but these measures are not humane. They are unusually cruel. It seems like not enough people are talking about the new crisis being created by the lockdown meant to prevent the COVID-19 outbreak crisis behind bars — and that new crisis is a mental health crisis.

We have been locked down for so long, it is impossible to maintain a positive outlook, to “keep your head up.” There has to be another way to prevent an outbreak in the prison system. One of the things that makes this lockdown so challenging is the constant rush once you’re let out your cell for the 45 minutes allotted a day. You’re rushing to the shower, rushing to try and sync your tablet, rushing to call a loved one and then rushing them off the phone when you’re told to lock in — which seems like 5 minutes after you started talking to them. 

For inmates who have legal deadlines or are genuinely trying to accomplish something, trying to really better themselves or maybe strengthen or repair some relationships — and data shows supportive relationships are key to lowering recidivism — this lockdown is complete torture and works against all of those efforts.

The lockdown has impacted in the most detrimental ways, every aspect of our social life. When our cell doors are briefly opened once a day, you can barely hold a conversation with anyone on your block because you’re trying so desperately to get the necessities done, like take a shower, make a phone call, check the kiosk or sync your tablet. These crucial and key activities leave little room for anything else. And after a while, you start to feel more isolated than you ever have. What part of the punishment was this?

Depression, anxiety, frustration and hopelessness come in unpredictably constant waves as a result of this cruel “preventive” measure. After being locked down for this long, you start to ask yourself: Am I better off dead?

Close window X

Republish this article

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Prison Journalism Project is happy to share our writers and reporters’ stories with your print and online audiences. You are free to republish them under a Creative Commons license unless otherwise noted on the page. You can use the URL or copy and paste the story into your CMS.

Here are our ground rules:

• You must credit Prison Journalism Project. In the byline, we prefer “[Author Name], Prison Journalism Project.” At the top of the text of your story, please include a line that says: “This story was originally published by Prison Journalism Project” and include a link to the article.
• No republishing of photographs, illustrations or graphics without specific permission. Please contact inquiries@prisonjournalismproject.org.
• No editing the content, including the headline, except to reflect changes in time, location and editorial style. For example, changing, “today” to “last week,” or San Quentin to San Quentin, California. You can also make minor revisions for style or headline size, and you can trim stories for space. You must also retain all original hyperlinks, including links to the Prison Journalism Project newsletters.
• No translation of our stories into another language without specific permission. Please contact inquiries@prisonjournalismproject.org.
• No selling ads against our stories, but you can publish it on a page with ads that you’ve already sold.
• No reselling or syndicating our stories, including on platforms or apps like Apple News or Google News. You also can’t republish our work automatically or all at once. Please select them individually.
• No scraping our website or using our stories to populate websites designed to improve search rankings or gain revenue from network-based advertisements.
• Any site our stories appear on must have a prominent and effective way to contact you.
• If we send you a request to remove our story, you must do so immediately.
• If you share republished stories on social media, please tag Prison Journalism Project. We have official accounts on Twitter (@prisonjourn), Facebook (@prisonjournalism), Instagram (@prisonjournalism) and Linked In.
• Let us know when you share the story. Send us a note, so we can keep track.

Am I Better Off Dead?

by Manuel Pagan Jr., Prison Journalism Project
June 4, 2021

<h1>Am I Better Off Dead?</h1> <p class="byline">by Manuel Pagan Jr., Prison Journalism Project <br />June 4, 2021</p> <br /> <h4>Am I Better Off Dead?</h4> <p>Was I better off dead<br />Than to be stuck in my head?<br />23 hours a day<br />For damn near a year straight.</p> <p>In response to one crisis,<br />They created another:<br />A pandemic of mental health illnesses<br />We now suffer.</p> <p>This one-year lockdown,<br />An unexpected abnormality,<br />Has me struggling to maintain<br />My grip on reality.</p> <p>Am I better off dead<br />And at peace with myself<br />Than to be cruelly and unusually punished<br />In this beast that’s my cell?</p> <h4>COMMENTARY</h4> <p>This poem is an attempt to capture the unbelievable amount of stress placed on inmates who have been forced — in the name of “safety” — to be locked down for an entire year, to prevent the spread of COVID-19 through the prison system.</p> <p>I don’t mean to suggest I’m suicidal as a result of this lockdown, but I wonder how many of us are. On the one hand, preventative measures were needed to prevent a prisonwide outbreak in the jails, but these measures are not humane. They are unusually cruel. It seems like not enough people are talking about the new crisis being created by the lockdown meant to prevent the COVID-19 outbreak crisis behind bars — and that new crisis is a mental health crisis.</p> <p>We have been locked down for so long, it is impossible to maintain a positive outlook, to “keep your head up.” There has to be another way to prevent an outbreak in the prison system. One of the things that makes this lockdown so challenging is the constant rush once you’re let out your cell for the 45 minutes allotted a day. You’re rushing to the shower, rushing to try and sync your tablet, rushing to call a loved one and then rushing them off the phone when you’re told to lock in — which seems like 5 minutes after you started talking to them.&nbsp;</p> <p>For inmates who have legal deadlines or are genuinely trying to accomplish something, trying to really better themselves or maybe strengthen or repair some relationships — and data shows supportive relationships are key to lowering recidivism — this lockdown is complete torture and works against all of those efforts.</p> <p>The lockdown has impacted in the most detrimental ways, every aspect of our social life. When our cell doors are briefly opened once a day, you can barely hold a conversation with anyone on your block because you’re trying so desperately to get the necessities done, like take a shower, make a phone call, check the kiosk or sync your tablet. These crucial and key activities leave little room for anything else. And after a while, you start to feel more isolated than you ever have. What part of the punishment was this?</p> <p>Depression, anxiety, frustration and hopelessness come in unpredictably constant waves as a result of this cruel “preventive” measure. After being locked down for this long, you start to ask yourself: Am I better off dead?</p> <p>This <a target="_blank" href="https://prisonjournalismproject.org/2021/06/04/am-i-better-off-dead/">article</a> first appeared on <a target="_blank" href="https://prisonjournalismproject.org">Prison Journalism Project</a> and is republished here under a Creative Commons license.<img src="https://i0.wp.com/prisonjournalismproject.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/cropped-PJP-favicon-2.png?fit=150%2C150&amp;ssl=1" style="width:1em;height:1em;margin-left:10px;"><img id="republication-tracker-tool-source" src="https://prisonjournalismproject.org/?republication-pixel=true&post=1383&ga=" style="width:1px;height:1px;"></p>

1